Friday, September 21, 2018

"Between Brock Turner & Brett Kavanaugh, when do girls matter?" - Simcha Fisher

Most people know who Brock Turner is, and if you don't he is a rapist.  Not "Stanford's former swimmer" as the media loves to call him in most articles revolving him or his case.  When Brock Turner was in court for violently raping an unconscious young woman behind a dumpster in an alley, his father made sure to say his sentence they were considering was "a steep price to pay for 20 minutes of action".  In the end judge Aaron Persky sentenced Brock Turner to only six months in jail because sending him away for any longer would ruin his future, while his maximum sentence for his crimes were 14 years.  After serving only three months in jail he was released.  Brett Kavanaugh is, now, a grown man who is an attorney as well as a jurist who at the age of 17 tried to rape a 15 year old girl.  He pinned her down on a bed at a house party, was grinding against her, tried tearing off her clothing and covered her mouth with his hand when she tried to scream.  Yet everyone is saying, "He was drunk when he did it, we all do stupid things when we're drunk", "At seventeen, his brain was still developing so his culpability is reduced", and the most talked about defense for Kavanaugh, "It happened long ago.  There's no indication he's still like that.  We're really going to hold him responsible for something that happened so long ago?".  The answer is yes.  We are still going to hold him responsible.  While all these people are making these statements, you can see in each of them they are acknowledging he in fact did do what Christine Blasey Ford is accusing him of doing, and they are okay with it.  So when do the girls in these terrible crimes matter?  They become liars, sluts, bitches and are shamed for the rest of their lives for coming forward, whether they spoke up the day it happened or years later.
My two favorite quotes from Simcha Fisher about this are "If you don't want men to be dragged down by decades-old accusations of rape, then you need to crack down on minutes-old accusations of rape as they happen." and "When a woman says "This man raped me a long time ago", we say, "But that was in the past.  He can't change the past."  When a girls says, "This boy raped me last night," we say "But his future!  We can't wreck his future."  And there she stands, suspended between his past and his future, with no value of her own."

7 comments:

  1. Honestly all of this is completely disgusting to me,and it really shows just how patriarchal societies believe that they can get away with anything simply because they run the societies. It also tells us just how women are viewed in these types of societies as well, and it's really heartbreaking to hear that these women are pushed to the side because society takes the rapists' side in it all.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What proof do you have that Ford's accusation is real and not just a political attempt by the Democrats to obstruct his confirmation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My post is not about whether or not the accusations are true and it is in no way about politics, that is why I did not mention anything about politics. Also, my post revolves around how the juice system treats women and girls in these situations. My point in this is that even if these accusations are not true, that society and the justice system tried pushing aside an act that may or may not been true because it was "in the past" the same way society and the justice system push aside assaults when they happen because they don't want to "wreck or ruin" the attackers future.

      Delete
    2. I agree - accusations should not be criticized or immediately shot down until an investigation is completed. This is exactly why some states are getting rid of their statute of limitations. I usually sympathize with all victims; however, the Kavanaugh case in particular is strikingly odd considering the circumstance.

      Delete
  3. This is all an awful failure of the justice system, and proof that there are many things that need to be rectified, fast. It's the argument that the victim coming forward is ruining the rapist's future that makes me angriest--the rapist likely ruined the victim's future with the trauma they now have to live with, whereas it's their own actions that would supposedly ruin theirs. And it seems, as shown in these accounts and likely others, that the rapist hardly ever faces proper consequences at all.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is very sad how the survivors are treated. They should go to prison for their actions!

    ReplyDelete
  5. It makes me sick to see how victims/survivors are usually treated following their attacks. It is sad that we live in a world that is more worried about saving an athletes 'career' than protecting the mind and body of a woman.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.