After the fact, Abigail, the victim in this case, texted friends for advice: " “I was like, ‘I feel violated. This feels wrong. But I don’t know if it’s illegal.’” "
The article states that "Abigail was right to be confused. Under her state’s law, what Grant did was not technically illegal — even though he later admitted that he knew Abigail wasn’t consenting to sex with him. That’s because in Indiana, sex only becomes rape when it’s compelled through force or threats, if the victim is mentally disabled and can’t properly consent, or if he or she is unaware that the sex is occurring."
As stated, this leaves a terrifying loophole in the law not only in Indiana "but more than three-quarters of US states and territories: The word consent, when it does appear in a statute, is not expressly defined in laws." This means consent obtained through deception or impersonation is not technically illegal. These cases have appeared for many years--the offender in a case from 1884 was found guilty, as the judges ruled that he knew the victim believed him to be her husband. However, in this case, the verdict wasn't so.
"During the three-day trial, defense attorney Kirk Freeman argued that while Grant’s conduct was “ungentlemanly” it wasn’t illegal under Indiana law. The jury agreed."
I found this verdict appalling, and the case one that I'd never even thought I'd see. What do you think?
This is just disgusting, there is no justifiable reason for this loophole to be in place. The word consent needs to be expressly defined in laws. What the heck, how many people have gotten off with raping another person because of this, it is not right and very unethical.
ReplyDelete