Sunday, October 21, 2018

Battle of the Sexes

The "battle of the sexes" trope is one that's gotten pretty frustrating. It's one that I actually forgot about until last weekend, when I visited the Carolina Renaissance Festival with my roommate and a couple of our friends. We were all in costume--I was in a medieval-style dress and surcoat, and my roommate in chainmail--and the general reception to both of us was positive, as these communities are at their best. (One of the performers even told us we looked badass!) The issue actually came when we sat down to watch the final joust of the day. It's the event that most attendees flock to, because it's advertised as a battle to the death. Of the four participants in the joust, three were men and one was a woman, which I was delighted by until the announcer drew attention to it by calling out that "it looks like we've got a bit of a battle of the sexes here, hmmm?"

That phrase immediately broke any enthrallment I had, because it took what was a great source of representation for the audience and turned it into a cheap gimmick. The connotations of that concept really need to be examined, because it is at its core problematic. For one, it reinforces the link between sex and gender. Those do not always coincide, and while it doesn't harm people for whom they do coincide to break that link, it does harm those for whom it doesn't to reinforce it. For another, it implies that men and women can't compete against each other without representing their entire gender, which is obviously absurd. Further, that concept tends to only harm women. Put simply:

( https://xkcd.com/385/ )

While this isn't a conscious opinion for most people, it very likely does exist, hindering real women's attempts at progress.

Anyway, while I'm fed up with the concept of a "battle of the sexes," I'm only one person. What do you think?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.